I have to admit, I haven't been paying a lot of attention to the Ontario election so far. Perhaps, and you may want to have your pitchforks and torches handy, it's because I'm generally satisfied with what the McGuinty government has done over the last eight years.
Investment in the auto makers, the HST, all-day kindergarten, green energy -- while unpopular with some, are policies that will benefit Ontario significantly in the long run.
There are certainly things I could find fault with: chiefly the incompetent management of several of the province's programs, agencies and commissions. But these problems often had their origins in the Harris years; the Liberals' fault lay mainly in not dealing with them sooner. But then, they had a huge mess to clean up.
However, I'm not going to expend time and energy critiquing, or even poking fun at Tim Hudak and the Conservatives.
I really don't have to: Rob Ford and the American Tea Partiers are doing a pretty good job undermining Hudak's credibility on his promise to cut taxes and balance the budget without cutting programs.
I'm just going to state the fundamental reason why I'm opposed to conservative political ideology and leave it at that.
It comes down to the difference between a "taxpayer" and a "citizen":
A taxpayer sees his or her condition as a victim of government. Taxes are a form of confiscation and so the best thing politicians can do is cut them. Always. Conservatives thus appeal to narrow self-interest. But I don't object just on moral grounds. This narrow self-interest is also short-sighted, because as every business person knows, you can't starve an enterprise to greatness; you have to spend money to make money.
A citizen, on the other hand, sees his- or herself as part of a community and a larger society. Taxes are a form of investment, a contribution to our social capital that pays future dividends in the form of a better and more prosperous future for all. Citizens recognize the need for taxes to rise when the situation warrants.
Of the three major parties contesting the election, I see Dalton McGuinty's Liberals as the party most aligned with this vision of Ontario as one comprised of citizens, working together, contributing to a better future for all.
I have to say something about Andrea Horwath and her New Democrats. I've supported the New Democrats most of my life, but I'm disappointed that Horwath has chosen to go fishing in the same anti-tax waters as Hudak: promising to remove the HST from home heating and reduce gasoline taxes. Progressive people should not be anti-tax, particularly taxes that contribute to combatting the effects of climate change.
So, I'm going to leave it there. I welcome your comments.
You can now follow me on Twitter: @AeneasLane
Radical libertarians, aka tea partiers, aka Milton Freedman, see taxation as theft and forced labour, as we own ourselves and no one has the right to take things from us. They are lunatics, stupid and dangerous lunatics. They appeal only to the worst ideas and feelings. Most tellingly they are not by nature democratic.
ReplyDeletePaul Murray, your a left wing kook...and I love ya! I'm afraid if things continue in Europe and go south in the states leading to a Republican win, we will be in the middle of the worst mess we have ever seen. A Hudak win would just bring it that much closer to home that much more quickly.
ReplyDeleteBrian MacIsaac